Joseph Ashley Garcia admitted on the stand that he poured tiki torch oil on his father and lit him on fire. He said he did not intend to kill him. He also confirmed that when he saw the flames, he did not call for help.

His father, 68-year-old Joseph Michael Garcia Sr., survived the initial fire. He was taken to the hospital with second and third-degree burns covering 35 percent of his body. Ten days later, he died from septic shock during skin graft surgery.

What Happened That Afternoon in Lompoc

Police responded to a 911 call on a June afternoon in 2022 at a home in Lompoc, California. What they found was the result of a collision between methamphetamine use, fractured relationships, and accusations that had taken hold of Garcia Jr.'s thinking in a deeply destructive way.

Garcia Jr. had become convinced that his spouse and his father were having an affair. Under questioning from his attorney, he went further, testifying that he believed his spouse, his father, his landlords, and others were part of a human trafficking and child pornography ring. Investigators found a bottle partially filled with acetone, a lighter, and a large machete at the scene.

Garcia Jr. had been a recognizable figure in Lompoc before his arrest, known for his marijuana advocacy and for occasionally speaking at city council meetings. That version of him was already far removed from the man who stood trial.

The Insanity Plea and What the Jury Decided

Garcia Jr. pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. Two court-appointed doctors evaluated him and came back with differing conclusions about whether he was legally sane at the time of the offense. The disagreement gave the defense something to work with, but it was not enough.

On April 13, 2026, the jury convicted Garcia of first-degree murder with a torture special circumstance. Eight days later, on April 21, the same jury rejected his insanity plea and found him legally sane at the time of the crime. With the torture special circumstance attached to the verdict, California law leaves no room for parole. Garcia faces a mandatory sentence of life without the possibility of release. Sentencing is scheduled before Judge Stephen Dunkle at Santa Maria Superior Court.

What Happened to Charlie

Garcia Sr.'s dog, Charlie, had been sitting on his lap when the fire started. Charlie fled the house with serious burns. He was captured near the scene, badly injured but alive.

A Los Alamos resident took Charlie in, cared for him through his recovery, and found him a new home once he healed. The dog who was on Garcia Sr.'s lap during the worst moment of his life made it out. He was adopted and is living with a new family.