justice
Ohio Man Gets $1.3 Million After 21 Years in Prison for Crime With No Evidence
OHIO MAN WINS $1.3 MILLION SETTLEMENT AFTER 21 years in prison for a crime scene investigators never found evidence for
Ralph Blaine Smith spent 21 years in prison for a home invasion that left no footprints in the snow at the crime scene.
The state of Ohio awarded him $1.3 million after evidence suggested the crime might never have happened at all.
Smith was 24 years old when he was arrested in February 2000 for an alleged armed robbery in Pickerington, Ohio.
The victim, Rudy Stefanitsis, reported that two masked Black men had broken into his home and forced him to open a safe containing $10,000 in cash, rare comic books, and jewelry.
No Evidence Connected Smith to the Scene
The original handwritten police report from 2000 noted something crucial: "Upon arrival, we secured the outer perimeter, noting a lack of fresh footprints in the snow."
Police never recovered any of the alleged stolen items.
No physical or forensic evidence tied Smith to the crime, according to the National Registry of Exonerations.
Smith's photo was identified by the family from a lineup where investigators placed small pieces of paper over the photos to simulate the masks the robbers allegedly wore.
Two Decades Studying Law Behind Bars
Smith refused to accept his conviction.
He spent most of his prison years in the law library, studying case law and filing appeals to prove his innocence.
"I fought hard studying case law, reading the law books, just being there for hours and hours," Smith said.
His persistence paid off when a judge in Fairfield County granted him a new trial in 2021 after discovering prosecutors had withheld evidence during his original trial.
Freedom and Settlement
Rather than conduct a second trial, prosecutors dropped all charges.
Smith walked free on July 4, 2021, moved to tears after spending 21 years behind bars.
His son had been born shortly before his conviction in 2000.
Smith said the settlement will help him care for his family, who supported him throughout his incarceration with visits and phone calls.
He was 49 years old when he tasted freedom again, awarded $1.3 million by a state that had taken half his life for a crime that may never have occurred.